13th Circuit Court Civil Records
Circuit Court Civil Records
13th Circuit Court
Antrim County 13TH CIRCUIT COURT-- Phone (231) 533-6353
PO BOX 520 -- 207 CAYUGA ST
BELLAIRE, MI 49615

Case #:   2020-9238 CZ   County:  Antrim
Case Type:   OTHER GENERAL CIVIL   



Trial Type:    Jury Demand: N
Judge:  ELSENHEIMER, KEVIN A.  P-Number: 49293
Date Issued:  11/23/2020  Date Closed: 03/03/2021   Date Expired: 
Date Reopened:  03/04/2021  Date Reclosed:  
Disposition: DISMISSED   Code: DSC  DISMISSED BY COURT 
Disposition Date: 03/03/2021 Judgment for: 


Litigants


NamePlaintiff/Defendant Attorney P-Number Alias
BAILEY, WILLIAMPlaintiffDEPERNO, MATTHEW S 52622
ANTRIM COUNTYDefendantKAZIM, HAIDER A. 66146
VANDER LAAN, ALLAN C. 33893

Court Proceedings


DateActionProceeding
11/23/2020SISUMMONS ISSUED (1) TO EXPIRE ON 2/22/2020/FILING
FEE PAID RCPT#35771 $175/NO JURY DEMAND FILED/
COMPLAINT FILED/ 11/23/2020
11/23/2020MOEPLTF'S MOTION AN EX PARTE TEMPORARY RESTRAINING
ORDER SHOW CAUSE ORDER AND PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
11/23/2020
11/23/2020MBPLTF'S BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR AN EX PARTE
TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER SHOW CAUSE ORDER, AND
PRELIMINARY INJUNCTIONS/ 11/23/2020
11/30/2020HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S MOTION FOR EX PARTE TRO
SHOW CAUSE ORDER AND PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
12/3/2020 @9:30AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM /11/25/20
11/30/2020APAPPEARANCE FILED-HAIDER KAZIM FOR DEF'TS ANTRIM
COUNTY/11/30/2020
MIFILE POS
11/30/2020PROOF OF SERVICE/11/30/2020
MIFILE POS
12/01/2020ATTACHMENT TO DEF'TS BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF RESPONSE
TO PLTF'S MOTION FOR AN EX PARTE TEMPORARY
RESTRAINING ORDER SHOW CAUSE ORDER AND
PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION EXHIBIT A /12/1/2020
12/01/2020MRDEF'TS BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF RESPONSE TO PLTF'S
MOTION FOR AN EX PARTE TEMPORARY RESTRAINING
ORDER SHOW CAUSE ORDER AND PRELIMINARY
INJUNCTION/12/1/2020
MIFILE POS
12/01/2020ATTACHMENT TO DEF'TS BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF RESPONSE
TO PLTF'S MOTION FOR AN EX PARTE TEMPORARY
RESTRAINING ORDER SHOW CAUSE ORDER AND PRELIM
INJUNCTION-EXHIBIT B 12/1/2020
MIFILE POS
12/01/2020ATTACHMENT TO DEF'TS BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF
RESPONSE TO PLTF'S MOTION FOR AN EX PARTE
TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER, SHOW CAUSE ORDER,
AND PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION -EXHIBIT C/12/1/2020
MIFILE POS
12/01/2020PROOF OF SERVICE/12/1/2020
12/01/2020MRDEF'TS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S MOTION FOR AN EX PARTE
TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER, SHOW CAUSE ORDER,
AND PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION/12/1/2020
MIFILE POS
12/02/2020MBPLTF'S SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR
AN EX PARTE TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER, SHOW
CAUSE ORDER, AND PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION/12/2/2020
MIFILE POS
12/02/2020MBEXHIBITS 7-8 TO PLTF'S SUPP BRIEF IN SUPPORT/
12/2/2020
12/02/2020MBEXHIBITS 1-6 TO PLTF'S SUPP BRIEF IN SUPPORT
12/2/2020
12/02/2020MBEXHIBITS 9-10 TO PLTF'S SUPP BRIEF IN SUPPORT
12/2/2020
MIFILE POS
12/03/2020MBPLTF'S SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF
MOTION FOR AN EX PARTE TEMPORARY RESTRAINING
ORDER SHOW CAUSE ORDER, AND PRELIMINARY
INJUNCTION/12/3/2020
MIFILE POS
12/04/2020ORDECISION AND ORDER REGARDING PLTF'S MOTION FOR AN
EX PARTE TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER-SHOW CAUSE
ORDER-AND PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION/KAE 12/4/2020
12/09/2020MBSECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSONS BRIEF IN
SUPPORT OF EMERGENCY MOTION TO INTERVENE AS
PARTY DEFENDANT/12/9/2020
12/09/2020ANDEF'T SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSONS ANSWER TO
PLTF'S COMPLAINT/ 12/9/2020
MIFILE POS
12/09/2020MOESECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSONS EMERGENCY
MOTION TO INTERVENE AS PARTY DEFENDANT/12/9/2020
MIFILE POS
12/09/2020HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN
BENSONS EMERGENCY MOTION TO INTERVENE AS PARTY
DEF'T 12/10/2020@3PM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
12/09/2020SECRETARY OF STATE'S EMERGENCY MOTION TO INTERVENE
AS PARTY DEF'T EXHIBIT 1/12/9/2020
MIFILE POS
12/10/2020MBPLTF'S RESPONSE TO SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN
BENSON'S EMERGENCY MOTION TO INTERVENE AS PARTY
DEFT'/12/10/2020
MIFILE POS
12/10/2020EXHIBIT 1 TO PLTF'S RESPONSE TO SECRETARY OF STATE
JOCELYN BENSONS' EMERGENCY MOTION TO INTERVENE
AS PARTY DEF'T/12/10/2020
MIFILE POS
12/11/2020HRGNOTICE OF PRE TRIAL CONFERENCE HEARING-12/15/2020
@9AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
12/11/2020ANDEF'T ANTRIM COUNTY'S ANSWER TO PLTF'S VERIFIED
COMPLAINT/ 12/11/2020
MIFILE POS
12/11/2020DEF'T ANTRIM COUNTY'S AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES/12/11
MFILE POS
12/11/2020PROOF OF SERVICE/12/11/2020
MIFILE POS
12/11/2020DEF'T ANTRIM COUNTY'S AMENDED AFFIRMATIVE
DEFENSES/12/11/2020
MIFILE POS
12/11/2020PROOF OF SERVICE/ 12/11/2020
MIFILE POS
12/11/2020NOENOTICE OF ENTRY UNDER 7 DAY RULE/12/11/2020
MIFILE POS
12/14/2020EXHIBIT 1 PLTF'S PROPOSED ORDER/12/14/2020
MIFILE POS
12/14/2020MRSECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSONS' RESPONSE TO
PLTF'S MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM ORDER AND FOR
CLARIFICATION OF SCOPE/12/14/2020
EXHIBIT B/EXHIBIT D/EXHIBIT C -SEALED/
EXHIBIT A/EXHIBIT LIST
MIFILE POS
12/14/2020MOPLTF'S AMENDED EX PARTE EMERGENCY MOTION AND
BRIEF FOR RELIEF FROM ORDER AND FOR
CLARIFICATION OF SCOPE/12/14/2020
MIFILE POS
12/14/2020HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S AMENDED EX PARTE
EMERGENCY MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM ORDER AND FOR
CLARIFICATION OF SCOPE 12/14/2020 @8:30AM IN
TRAVERSE CITY VIA ZOOM
12/14/2020ORDECISION AND ORDER REGARDING PRELIMINARY REPORT
AND OTHER DATA/KAE 12/14/2020
12/15/2020ORORDER GRANTING PLTF'S AMENDED EMERGENCY EX PARTE
MOTION AND BRIEF FOR RELIEF FROM ORDER AND
CLARIFICATION OF SCOPE/KAE 12/15/2020
MIFILE POS
12/16/2020SCOCOURTS CIVIL SCHEDULING CONFERENCE ORDER/12/16/20
12/16/2020CORRESPONDENCE RE-DEPS DATE/12/16/2020
12/16/2020HRGNOTICE OF SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE-3/10/2021 @9AM IN
BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
12/16/2020NJTNOTICE OF TWO DAY NON JURY TRIAL-4/7-4/8/2021
@8:30AM IN BELLAIRE
12/17/2020PROOF OF SERVICE/12/17/2020
MIFILE POS
12/17/2020SCOFIRST AMENDED CIVIL SCHEDULING CONFERENCE ORDER
12/17/2020
12/21/2020ORORDER GRANTING INTERVENTION BY SOS JOCELYN
BENSON/12/21/2020
MIFILE POS
12/22/2020MOPLTF'S MOTION AND BRIEF FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/
12/22/2020
MIFILE POS
12/22/2020PLTF'S RESPONSE TO DEF'T SECRETARY OF STATES
FIRST SET OF REQUESTS TO ADMIT/12/22/2020
MIFILE POS
12/22/2020PROOF OF SERVICE/12/22/2020
MIFILE POS
12/22/2020HRGNOTICE OF HEARING=-PLTF'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE
ORDER 1/11/2021 @9:30AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
12/23/2020PROOF OF SERVICE/12/23/2020
MIFILE POS
12/23/2020PROOF OF SERVICE/12/23/2020
MIFILE POS
12/23/2020DEF'T ANTRIM COUNTY'S WITNESS LIST/EXPERT WITNESS
LIST/AND EXHIBIT LIST/12/23/2020
MIFILE POS
12/23/2020PROOF OF SERVICE 12/23/2020
MIFILE POS
12/23/2020PLT'FS PRELIMINARY WITNESS LIST/12/23/2020
MIFILE POS
12/23/2020PLTF'S PRELIMINARY EXHIBIT LIST/12/23/2020
MIFILE POS
12/30/2020INTERVENOR- DEFENDANT'S EXHIBIT LIST
12/23/2020
MIFILE POS
12/30/2020INTERVENOR-DEFENDANT'S EXPERT DISCLOSURE
12/23/2020
MIFILE POS
12/30/2020INTERVENOR-DEFENDANT'S WITNESS LIST
12/23/2020
MIFILE POS
12/30/2020PROOF OF SERVICE- INTERVENOR- EXHIBITS
12/23/2020
MIFILE POS
12/30/2020PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT WITNESS LIST
12/23/2020
TRUEFILING PROOF OF SERVICE- MISC
12/23/2020
12/30/2020PROOF OF MAILING-PLT'S WITNESS LIST
PLT'S EXHIBIT LIST
12/23/2020
TRUEFILING PROOF OF SERVICE- POS
12/23/2020
12/30/2020MBRESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER
12/29/2020
MIFILE POS
01/04/2021MOPLTF'S MOTION AND BRIEF TO COMPEL DISCOVERY
AGAINST INTERVENOR-DEF'T BENSON/1/4/2021
MIFILE POS
01/04/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S MOTION TO COMPEL
DISCOVERY AGAINST INTERVENOR-DEFENDANT BENSON/
1/11/2021 @9:30AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
01/04/2021EXHIBITS 1-3 TO PLTF'S MOTION AND BRIEF TO COMPEL
DISCOVERY AGAINST INTERVENOR-DEF'T BENSON/1/4/21
MIFILE POS
01/04/2021EXHIBIT 4-PLTF'S MOTION AND BRIEF TO COMPEL
DISCOVERY AGAINST INTERVENOR DEF'T BENSON/1/4/21
MIFILE POS
01/05/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/1/5/2021
MIFILE POS
01/05/2021DEFENDANT ANTRIM COUNTY'S FIRST REQUESTS TO ADMIT
TO PLAINTIFF/1/5/2021
MIFILE POS
01/08/2021MRINTERVENOR-DEF'T JOCELYN BENSON'S RESPONSE TO
PLTF'S MOTION TO COMPEL 1/8/2021
MIFILE POS
01/08/2021MRDEFT ANTRIM COUNTY'S JOINDER AND CONCURRENCE IN
INTERVENOR-DEF'T SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN
BENSONS RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLTF'S MOTION
FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/1/08/2021
MIFILE POS
01/11/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/1/11/2021
MIFILE POS
01/13/2021PLTFS RESPONSE TO DEFT ANTRIM COUNTY'S FIRST
REQUEST TO ADMIT TO PLTF/1/13/2021
MIFILE POS
01/13/2021NOENOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER UNDER THE 7 DAY RULE/
1/13/2021
MIFILE POS
01/13/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/1/13/2021
MIFILE POS
01/19/2021NOESEVEN DAY NOTICE OF PRESENTMENT/1/19/2021
MIFILE POS
01/19/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/1/19/2021
MIFILE POS
01/21/2021ORORDER DENYING PTLFS' MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/
KAE 1/21/2021
MIFILE POS
01/25/2021TRATRANSCRIPT FILED-PLTF'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE
ORDER AND PLTF'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY
AGAINST INTERVENOR DEF'T BENSON VIA ZOOM
HEARD ON 1/11/2021 BY JUDGE ELSENHEIMER REPORTED
BY CSR JAYNES 7597/FILED 1/25/2021
01/25/2021CORRESPONDENCE REGARDING DISCOVERY DATES/1/25/2021
01/26/2021HRGAMENDED NOTICE OF SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE 5/11/2021
@9AM IN BELLAIRE
01/26/2021NJTNOTICE OF TWO DAY NON JURY TRIAL 6/8/2021 -6/9/21
@8:30AM IN BELLAIRE
01/26/2021ORSTIPULATED ORDER EXTENDING DATES/KAE 1/26/2021
MIFILE POS
01/26/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/1/26/2021
MIFILE POS
01/27/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/1/27/2021
MIFILE POS
01/29/2021ORORDER GRANTING PLTF'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY
AGAINST INTERVENOR DEF'T BENSON/1/29/2021
MIFILE POS
02/22/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/2/22/2021
MIFILE POS
02/26/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/2/26/2021
MIFILE POS
02/26/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/2/26/2021
MIFILE POS
03/03/2021DSCLERK'S DISMISSAL FOR NON SERVICE ON DEF'T ANTRIM
COUNTY/3/3/2021 /W/PROOF OF SERVICE TO PARTY
03/03/2021DSCLERK'S DISMISSAL FOR NON SERVICE ON DEFT/
INTERVENOR-SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSON/
3/3/2021W/PROOF OF SERVICE
03/04/2021ORERRATA ORDER SETTING ASIDE DISMISSAL/KAE 3/4/2021
03/04/2021ORERRATA ORDER SETTING ASIDE DISMISSAL/KAE 3/4/2021
03/08/2021FIRST REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS DIRECTED TO
SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSON 3/8/2021
MIFILE POS
03/08/2021FIRST REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS DIRECTED TO ANTRIM
COUNTY/3/8/2021
MIFILE POS
03/08/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/3/8/2021
MIFILE POS
03/08/2021CORRECTED PROOF OF SERVICE/3/8/2021
MIFILE POS
03/09/2021MODEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO MODIFY COURT ORDERED
DISCOVERY PROCEDURES/3/9/2021
EXHIBITS A-G TO DEF'TS MOTION TO MODIFY 3/9/2021
MIFILE POS
03/09/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO MODIFY
COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY PROCEDURES/3/9/2021
MIFILE POS
03/10/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO MODIFY
COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY PROCEDURES-3/22/2021
@11:30AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
03/11/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF INTERVENOR DEF'T SECRETARY OF
STATES MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY/3/11/2021
MIFILE POS
03/11/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF INTERVENOR DEF'T SECRETARY OF
STATE'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY/3/11/2021
MIFILE POS
03/11/2021MOINTERVENOR DEF'T SECRETARY OF STATES MOTION TO
COMPEL DISCOVERY/3/11/2021
MIFILE POS
03/11/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/3/11/2021
MIFILE POS
03/11/2021CORRECTED FIRST REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS DIRECTED
TO ANTRIM COUNTY/3/11/2021
MIFILE POS
03/11/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/3/11/2021
MIFILE POS
03/11/2021CORRECTED FIRST REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS DIRECTED
TO SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSON/3/11/2021
MIFILE POS
03/12/2021HRGNOTICE OF MOTION HEARING-INTERVENOR DEF'T
SECRATARY OF STATE'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY
TO BE HEARD ON 3/22/2021 @11:30AM IN BELLAIRE
VIA ZOOM
03/15/2021MOINTERVENING DEF'TS MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/
3/15/2021
MIFILE POS
03/15/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF INTERVENING DEF'TS MOTION FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER/3/15/2021
MIFILE POS
03/15/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF INTERVENING DEF'TS MOTION FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER/3/15/2021
MIFILE POS
03/16/2021PROOF OF SERVICE-SUBPOENA-MACOMB COUNTY CLERK/
3/16/2021
MIFILE POS
03/16/2021PROOF OF SERVICE-SUBPOENA-OAKLAND COUNTY CLERK/
3/16/2021
MIFILE POS
03/16/2021PROOF OF SERVICE-SUBPOENA-KENT COUNTY CLERK/
3/16/2021
MIFILE POS
03/16/2021HRGNOTICE OF MOTION HEARING-INTERVENING DEF'TS MOTION
FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 3/22/2021 @11:30AM IN
BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
03/18/2021MODEF'TS JOINT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER PURSUANT
TO MCR 2.302(C)/3/17/2021
MIFILE POS
03/18/2021EXHIBITS TO DEF'TS JOINT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE
ORDER PURSUANT TO MCR 2.302(C)-EXHIBIT K/
EXHIBIT H/EXHIBIT O/EXHIBIT R/EXHIBIT A/EXHIBIT B
/EXHIBIT Q/EXHIBIT D/EXHIBIT P/EXHIBIT C/
EXHIBIT L/EXHIBIT F/EXHIBIT G/EXHIBIT N/EXHIBIT M
/EXHIBIT J/EXHIBIT E/EXHIBIT I/3/17/2021
MIFILE POS
03/18/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/3/17/2021
MIFILE POS
03/18/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEF'TS JOINT MOTION FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER PURSUANT TO MCR 2.302(C)/3/17/21
MIFILE POS
03/18/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-DEF'TS JOINT MOTION FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER PURSUANT TO MCR 2.302(C)
ON APRIL 12, 2021 @10:30AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
03/18/2021MOINTERVENOR DEF'T SECRETARY OF STATES MOTION TO
COMPEL DISCOVERY AND TO STRIKE PLTF'S EXPERT
WITNESSES/3/18/2021
MIFILE POS
03/18/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF INTERVENOR DEF'T SECRETARY OF
STATE'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY AND TO STRIKE
PLTF'S EXPERT WITNESSES/3/18/2021
MIFILE POS
03/18/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF INTERVENING -DEF'T SECRETARY
OF STATE'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY AND TO
STRIKE PLTF'S EXPERT WITNESSES/3/18/2021
MIFILE POS
03/18/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-INTERVENOR DEF'T SECRETARY OF
STATES MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY AND TO STRIKE
PLTF'S EXPERT WITNESS LIST-4/12/2021 @10:30AM
VIA ZOOM IN BELLAIRE
03/19/2021MRPLTF'S RESPONSE TO INTERVENOR DEF'TS MOTION FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER/3/19/2021
MIFILE POS
03/19/2021MRPLT'FS RESPONSE TO INTERVENOR DEF'T SECRETARY OF
STATE'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY/3/19/2021
MIFILE POS
03/19/2021MRPLTF'S RESPONSE TO DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO MODIFY
COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY PROCEDURES/3/19/2021
MIFILE POS
03/19/2021EXHIBIT 1 TO PLTF'S RESPONSE TO DEF'TS JOINT
MOTION TO MODIFY COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY
PROCEDURES/3/19/2021
MIFILE POS
03/19/2021APAPPEARANCE FILED-FRANK KRYCIA ON BEHALF ON NON-
PARTY SUBPOENA RECIPIENT MACOMB COUNTY CLERK-
ANTHONY FORLINI/3/19/2021
MIFILE POS
03/19/2021EXHIBIT 1-PLTF'S RESPONSE TO INTERVENOR DEF'T
SECRETARY OF STATE'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY/
3/19/2021
MIFILE POS
03/19/2021EXHIBITS 1-5 PLTF'S MOTION AND BRIEF FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER/3/22/2021
MIFILE POS
03/22/2021APAPPEARANCE FILED-BARRY COUNTY CLERK PAMELA PALMER
/3/22/2021
MIFILE POS
03/22/2021MOMOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA -NON PARTY BARRY COUNTY
CLERK PAMELA PALMER/3/22/2021
WITH EXHIBITS EXHIBIT A/EXHIBIT C/EXHIBIT B/
3/22/2021
MIFILE POS
03/22/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA BY
NON PARTY BARRY COUNTY CLERK PAMELA PALMER/
3/22/2021
MIFILE POS
03/24/2021HRGNOTICE OF MOTION HEARING-MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA
BY NON PARTY BARRY COUNTY CLERK PAMELA PALMER
4/12/2021 @10:30AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
03/24/2021MOLIVINGSTON COUNTY CLERK'S MOTION TO QUASH
SUBPOENA AND FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/3/24/2021
MIFILE POS
03/24/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF LIVINGSTON COUNTY CLERK'S
MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA AND FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER
3/24/2021
03/24/2021MBGRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY CLERK'S BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF
MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA AND FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER
3/24/2021
MIFILE POS
03/24/2021MOGRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY CLERK'S MOTION TO QUASH
SUBPOENA AND FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/3/24/2021
MIFILE POS
03/24/2021MOMACOMB COUNTY CLERK ANTHONY FORLINI'S MOTION TO
QUASH SUBPOENA AND FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/3/24/2021
MIFILE POS
03/24/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MACOMB COUNTY CLERK ANTHONY
FORLINI'S MOTION TO QUASH SUBPEONA AND FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER/3/24/2021
MIFILE POS
03/25/2021HRGNOTICE OF MOTION HEARING-MACOMB COUNTY CLERK
ANTHONY FORLINIS' MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA AND
FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 4/12/2021 @10:30AM IN
BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
03/25/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-LIVINGSTON COUNTY CLERK'S
MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA AND FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER
4/12/2021 @10:30AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
03/25/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY CLERK'S
MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA AND FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER
4/12/2021 @10:30AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
03/26/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/SUBPEONA CHARLEVOIX COUNTY CLERK
3/26/2021-MIFILE POS
03/26/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/SUBPOENA GRANT TRAVERSE COUNTY
CLERK/3/26/2021-MIFILE POS
03/26/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/SUBPOENA LIVINGSTON COUNTY CLERK
3/26/2021-MIFILE POS
03/26/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/SUBPOENA BARRY COUNTY CLERK-
3/26/2021-MIFILE POS
03/26/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/SUBPOENA WAYNE COUNTY-3/26/2021
MIFILE POS
03/26/2021MOPLTF'S MOTION AND BRIEF FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/
3/26/2021
MIFILE POS
03/26/2021EXHIBITS 1-5 PLTF'S MOTION AND BRIEF FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER/3/26/2021
MIFILE POS
03/26/2021PROOF OF SERVICE-SUBPOENA MILLER CONSULTATION AND
ELECTIONS INC-DBA ELECTION SOURCE/3/26/2021
MIFILE POS
03/29/2021FEE WAIVER REQUEST/GT COUNTY/3/29/2021
03/29/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE
ORDER-4/12/2021 @10:30AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
03/30/2021NOENOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER UNDER THE 7 DAY RULE/
3/30/2021
MIFILE POS
03/30/2021NOENOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER UNDER THE 7 DAY RULE/
3/31/2021
MIFILE POS
03/30/2021NOENOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER UNDER THE 7 DAY RULE/
3/30/2021
MIFILE POS
04/02/2021MOPLTF'S MOTION AND BRIEF TO EXTENDDISCOVERY AND
DATES/W/EXHIBIT 4/2/2021
MIFILE POS
04/05/2021HRGNOTICE OF MOTION HEARING-PLTF'S MOTION TO EXTEND
DISCOVERY AND DATES 4/12/2021 @10:30AM IN
BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/05/2021TRATRANSCRIPT FILED-MOTIONS VIA ZOOM HEARD BY JUDGE
ELSENHEIMER ON 3/22/2021 REPORTED BY CSR JAYNES
7597 FILED 4/5/2021
04/05/2021MIFILE POS
04/06/2021OBJPLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS
JOINT MOTION TO MODIFY COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY
PROCEDURES/4/6/2021
04/06/2021OBJPLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS
JOINT MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY/4/6/2021
MIFILE POS
04/06/2021OBJPLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED PROTECTIVE ORDER
REGARDING DISCOVERY REQUIREMENTS/4/6/2021
MIFILE POS
04/06/2021EXHIBITS 1-2 TO PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER
GRANTING DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO COMPEL
DISCOVERY/4/6/2021
MIFILE POS
04/06/2021EXHIBIT 1 TO PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED
PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DISCOVERY DOCUMENTS/
4/6/2021
MIFILE POS
04/06/2021EXHIBITS 1-2 PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER
GRANTING DEF'TS JOINT MOTIN TO MODIFY COURT
ORDERED DISCOVERY PROCEDURES/4/6/2021
MIFILE POS
04/07/2021PROOF OF SERVICE-FIFTH INTERR/4/7/2021
MIFILE POS
04/07/2021PROOF OF SERVICE-SUBPEONA VERIZON/4/7/2021
MIFILE POS
04/08/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED
ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO MODIFY
COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY PROCEDURES TO BE HEARD ON
4/23/2021 @9AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/08/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED
ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO COMPEL
DISCOVERY 4/23/2021 @9AM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/08/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED
PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DISCOVERY DOCUMENTS
TO BE HEARD ON 4/23/2021 @9AM IN BELLAIRE VIA
ZOOM-4/08/2021
04/09/2021PLTF'S FIRST AMENDED EXPERT WITNESS LIST/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT T TO BE ATTACHED TO DEF'TS
JOINT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER PURSUANT TO
MCR 2.302(C)/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT S TO BE ATTACHED TO DEF'TS
JOINT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER PURSUANT TO
MCR 2.302(C)4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021EXHIBIT 8-ATTACHMENT TO DEF'T ANTRIM COUNTY'S
RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLTF'S MOTION AND
BRIEF TO EXTEND DISCOVERY AND DATES AND BRIEF IN
SUPPORT-EXHIBIT 4/EXHIBIT 3/EXHIBIT 1/EXHIBIT 5/
EXHIBIT 6/EXHIBIT 7/EXHIBIT 2/
TRUEFILING POS-EXHIBIT 8
04/09/2021 MIFILE POS
04/09/2021MRDE'FT ANTRIM COUNTY'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO
PLTF'S MOTION AND BRIEF TO EXTEND DISCOVERY AND
DATES/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021MRBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DE'FT ANTRIM COUNTY'S RESPONSE
IN OPPOSITION TO PLTF'S MOTION AND BRIEF TO
EXTEND DISCOVERY AND DATES/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/4/9/2021
04/09/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEF'T ANTRIM COUNTY AND
SECRETARY OF STATE'S JOINT MOTION FOR SUMMARY
DISPOSITION PURSUANT TO MCR 2.116(C)(4)AND(8)/
4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021EXHIBIT LIST-BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEF'T ANTRIM
COUNTY AND SECRETARY OF STATE'S JOINT MOTION FOR
SUMMARY DISPOSITION PURSUANT TO MCR 2.116(C)(8)
4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021MODEF'TS JOINT MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION
PURSUANT TO MCR 2.116(C)(4) AND (8)/4/9/2021
04/09/2021MBINTERVENING DEF'T SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN
BENSONS BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO PLTF'S MOTION TO
EXTEND DISCOVERY AND DATES/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021MBINTERVENING DEF'T SECRETARY OF STATE'S RESPONSE IN
OPPOSITION TO PLT'FS MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/
4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021EXHIBIT LIST-BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO PLTF'S MOTION
FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021PLTF'S COLLECTIVE RESPONSE TO DEF'TS AND NON
PARTY COUNTIE'S MOTIONS TO QUASH AND FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDERS-EXHIBITS 5-9/EXHIBITS 10=14/
EXHIBIT 4/EXHIBITS 1-3/EXHIBITS 15-18/
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021MOPLTF'S MOTION TO EXCEED PAGE LIMIT/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021MBPLTF'S COLLECTIVE RESPONSE TO DEF'TS AND NON
PARTY COUNTIES MOTIONS TO QUASH AND FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDERS/4/09/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021MBPLTF'S SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021MBPLT'FS RESPONSE TO INTERVENOR DEF'TS MOTION TO
COMPEL DISCOVERY AND TO STRIKE PLTF'S EXPERT
WITNESS LIST/4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/09/2021INTERVENING DEF'T SECRETARY OF STATE'S BRIEF IN
OPPOSITION TO PLT'S MOTION TO EXTEND DISCOVERY
AND DATES-EXHIBIT LIST4/9/2021
MIFILE POS
04/12/2021NOENOTICE OF SUBMISSION OF ORDER
04/12/2021
MIFILE POS 04/12/2021
04/13/2021HRGNOTICE OF MOTION-DEFT'S JOINT MOTION FOR SUMMARY
DISPOSITION PURSUANT TO MCR 2.116(C)(4)AND (8)
SET FOR 05/10/2021 AT 1:30PM ZOOM MEETING
6276788320
04/13/2021
MIFILE POS
04/16/2021MOPLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND EXPERT
WITNESS LIST
04/15/2021
MIFILE POS
04/16/2021EXHIBIT 1- PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND
EXPERT WITNESS LIST
4/15/2021
MIFILE POS
04/16/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/4/16/2021
MIFILE POS
04/19/2021HRGNOTICE OF MOTION HEARING-PLTF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE
TO AMEND EXPERT WITNESS LIST-4/26/2021 @1:30PM IN
BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/19/2021TRATRANSCRIPT FILED-MOTIONS HEARD BY JUDGE
ELSENHEIMER ON 4/12/2021 REPORTED BY CSR JAYNES
7597/FILED 4/19/2021
04/19/2021NOENOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER UNDER 7 DAY RULE/4/19/21
MIFILE POS
04/19/2021NOENOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER UNDER 7 DAY RULE/4/19/21
MIFILE POS
04/19/2021NOENOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER UNDER 7 DAY RULE/4/19/21
MIFILE POS
04/20/2021MOPLTF'S MOTION TO ADJOURN HEARING ON DEF'TS
MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION AND CLARIFY
SCHEDULING ORDER/4/19/2021
MIFILE POS
04/20/2021EXHIBITS 1-3 PLTF'S MOTION TO ADJOURN HEARING ON
DEF'TS MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION/4/19/21
MIFILE POS
04/20/2021HRGNOTICE OF MOTION HEARING-PLTF'S MOTION TO ADJOURN
HEARING ON DEF'TS MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION
AND CLARIFYING SCHEDULING ORDER 4/26/2021 @1:30PM
IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/20/2021ORORDER GRANTING MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENAS/KAE
4/20/2021
MIFILE POS
04/20/2021INTERVENING DEF'TS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S OBJECTION
TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS MOTION TO
COMPEL DISCOVERY-EXHIBIT LIST/4/20/2021
MIFILE POS
04/20/2021MBINTERVENING DEF'TS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S OBJECTION TO
PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS MOTION TO COMPEL
DISCOVERY/4/20/2021
MIFILE POS
04/20/2021INTERVENING DEF'TS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S OBJECTION TO
PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO
MODIFY COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY PROCEDURES/4/20/21
MIFILE POS
04/20/2021MBINTERVENING DEF'TS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S OBJECTION TO
PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO
MODIFY COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY PROCEDURES/4/20/21
MIFILE POS
04/20/2021MBINTERVENING DEF'TS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S OBJECTION TO
PROPOSED PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DISCOVERY
DOCUMENTS/4/20/2021
MIFILE POS
04/20/2021INTERVENING DEF'TS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S OBJECTION TO
PROPOSED PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DISCOVERY
DOCUMENTS-EXHIBIT LIST/4/20/2021
MIFILE POS
04/21/2021MRDEF'T ANTRIM COUNTY'S JOINDER AND CONCURRENCE IN
INTERVENOR DEFT'S RESPONSE TO PLTF'S OBJECTIONS
TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO
MODIFY COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY PROCEDURES/4/21/21
MIFILE POS
04/21/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/4/21/2021
MIFILE POS
04/22/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/MISC SUBPOENAS/4/21/2021
MFILE POS
04/22/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/MISC SUBPEONAS/4/21/2021
MIFILE POS
04/22/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/MISC SUBPOENAS/4/21/2021
MIFILE POS
04/23/2021EXHIBIT LIST TO DEF'T SECRETARY OF STATE'S
RESPONSE TO PLTF'S MOTION TO ADJOURN HEARING ON
DEF'TS MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION AND CLARIFY
SCHEDULING ORDER/4/23/2021
MIFILE POS
04/23/2021MBDEF'TS JOINT RESPOSNE TO PLTF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE
TO AMEND EXPERT WITNESS LIST/4/23/2021
MIFILE POS
04/23/2021DEF'TS SECRETARY OF STATE AND ANTRIM COUNTY'S
BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF JOINT MOTION TO QUASH
NON PARTY SUBPEONAS TO DOMINION VOTING SYSTEMS
AND THE TOWNSHIPS OF BANKS, CENTRAL LAKE,
CHESTONIA, CUSTER, ECHO, ELK RAPIDS, FOREST HOME,
HELENA, JORDAN, KEARNEY, MANCELONA, MILTON, STAR
TORCH LAKE, AND WARNER-EXHIBIT LIST/4/23/2021
MIFILE POS
04/23/2021MBDEF'TS JOINT RESPONSE TO PLTF'S MOTION TO ADJOURN
HEARING ON DEF'TS JOINT MOTION FOR SUMMARY
DISPOSITION AND TO CLARIFY SCHEDULING ORDER/
4/23/2021
MIFILE POS
04/23/2021INTERVENING DEF'T JOCELYN BENSONS RESPONSE TO
PTLF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND EXPERT WITNESS
LIST-EXHIBIT LIST/4/23/2021
MIFILE POS
04/23/2021MBDEF'TS SECRETARY OF STATE AND ANTRIM COUNTY'S
BRIEF INSUPPORT OF JOINT MOTION TO QUASH NON
PARTY SUBPEONAS TO DOMINION VOTING SYSTEMS AND
THE TOWNSHIPS OF BANKS ET AL./4/23/2021
MIFILE POS
04/23/2021MODEF'TS SECRETARY OF STATE AND ANTRIMS COUNTY'S
JOINT MOTION TO QUASH NON PARTY SUBPEONAS TO
DOMINION VOTING SYSTEMS AND THE TOWNSHIPS OF
BANKS, ET AL./4/23/2021
MIFILE POS
04/26/2021OBJPLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS
JOINT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER W/ATTACHMENT
4/26/2021
MIFILE POS
04/26/2021OBJPLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING IN
PART AND DENYING IN PART PLTF' MOTION TO EXTEND
DICOVERY AND DATES W/ATTACHMENT/4/26/2021
MIFILE POS
04/26/2021PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS
MOTION TO COMPEL DEPOSITIONS AND DENYING MOTION
FOR A PROTECTIVE ORDER W/ATTACHMENT 4/26/2021
MIFILE POS
04/26/2021PROOF OF SERVICE-DEPOSITION NOTICES/4/26/2021
04/27/2021HRGNOTICE OF MOTION HEARING-DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO
QUASH NON PARTY SUBPEONAS TO DOMINION VOTING
SYSTEMS, AND BANKS TWP ET AL. TO BE HEARD ON
5/10/2021 @1:30PM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/27/2021ORORDER OF THE COURT/KAE 4/26/2021
MIFILE POS
04/27/2021HRGNOTICE OF MOTION HEARING-PLTF'S OBJECTION TO
PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING IN PARTY AND DENYING IN
PART PLTF'S MOTION TO EXTEND DISCOVERY DATES/
5/10/2021 @1:30PM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/27/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED
ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS JOINT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE
ORDER 5/10/2021 @1:30PM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/27/2021MONON PARTY TOWNSHIPS MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENAS
AND ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDERS/
4/27/2021 EXHIBITS TO MOTION AND BRIEF 4/27/2021
MIFILE POS
04/27/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF NON PARTY TOWNSHIPS MOTION TO
QUASH SUBPOENAS ASN ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER/4/27/2021
MIFILE POS
04/28/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-NON PARTY TOWNSHIPS MOTION TO Q
QUASH SUBPOENAS AND ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER TO BE HEARD ON 5/10/2021 @1:30PM
IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/29/2021OBJPLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSEDO RDER GRANTING
DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY/4/29/21
MIFILE POS
04/29/2021OBJPLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS
JOINT MOTION TO MODIFY COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY
PROCEDURES/4/29/2021
MIFILE POS
04/29/2021OBJPLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED PROTECTIVE ORDER
REGARDING DISCOVERY DOCUMENTS/4/29/2021
MIFILE POS
04/30/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/4/30/2021
MMIFILE POS
04/30/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED
PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DISCOVERY DOCUMENTS/
5/10/2021 @1:30PM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/30/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED
ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO MODIFY
COURT ORDERED DISCOVERY PROCEDURES 5/10/2021
@1;30PM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
04/30/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED
ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS JOINT MOTION TO COMPEL
DISCOVERY 5/10/2021 @1:30PM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM
05/03/2021TRATRANSCRIPT FILED-MOTIONS VIA ZOOM ON 4/26/2021
HEARD BY JUDGE ELSENHEIMER REPORTED BY CSR JAYNES
7597/FILED 5/3/2021
05/03/2021NOESEVEN DAY NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER/5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021MBPLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT MOTION FOR SUMMARY
DISPOSITION PURSUANT TO MCR 2.116(C)(4)AND(8)
5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT
MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION PURSUANT TO
MCR2.116(C)(4) AND (8)5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBITS 1-5 -PLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT MOTION FOR
SUMMARY DISPOSITION /5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBITS 13 PART 1 -PLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT
MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION/5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBITS 10-12 -PLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT MOTION
FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION/5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBITS 6-9-PLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT MOTION FOR
SUMMARY DISPOSITION/5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBITS 13 PART 2-PLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT MOTION
FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION/5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBITS 14 PART 1-PLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT MOTION
FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION/5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBITS 14-PART3-PLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT MOTION
FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION/5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBIT 1 PART 2-PLTF'S MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT
5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBIT 1 PART 1-PLTF'S MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT
5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021MOPLTF'S MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT/5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBITS 14 PART 2-PLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT MOTION
FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION/5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/03/2021EXHIBITS 14-19 -PLTF'S RESPONSE TO JOINT MOTION
FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION/5/3/2021
MIFILE POS
05/05/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT
5/18/2021 @1:30PM IN BELLAIRE VIA ZOOM/5/5/2021
05/06/2021NOESEVEN DAY NOTICE OF PRESENTMENT /5/6/2021
MIFILE POS
05/06/2021MOEDEF'TS EX PARTE MOTION FOR EXCESS PAGES/5/6/2021
MIFILE POS
05/06/2021DEF'TS JOINT REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR
SUMMARY DISPOSITION-EXHIBIT LIST/5/6/2021
MIFILE POS
05/06/2021MOPLTF'S EMERGENCY EX PARTE MOTION FOR STATUS
CONFERENCE AND TO AMEND MOTION SCHEDULE/5/6/2021
MIFILE POS
05/06/2021PROOF OF SERVICE 5/6/2021
MIFILE POS
05/06/2021EXHIBITS 1-2 TO PLTF'S EMERGENCY EX PARTE MOTION
FOR STATUS CONFERENCE AND TO AMEND MOTION
SCHEDULE/5/6/2021
MIFILE POS
05/07/2021APAPPEARANCE FILED-PETER WENDLING FOR NON PARTY
TOWNSHIPS/5/7/2021
MIFILE POS
05/07/2021MBDEF'TS JOINT REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR
SUMMARY DISPOSITION/5/7/2021
MIFILEPOS
05/07/2021MBDEF'TS BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR A PROTECTIVE
ORDER TO PRECLUDE THE DEPOSITION OF MICHIGAN
SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSON/5/7/2021
MIFILE POS
05/07/2021MODEF'TS MOTION FOR A PROTECTIVE ORDER TO PRECLUDE
THE DEPOSITION OF MICHIGAN SECRETARY OF STATE
JOCELYN BENSON/5/7/2021
MIFILE POS
05/07/2021DEF'TS MOTION FOR A PROTECTIVE ORDER TO PRECLUDE
THE DEPOSITION OF MICHIGAN SECRETARY OF STATE
JOCELYN BENSON/5/7/2021
MIFILE POS
05/07/2021INTERVENING DEF'T JOCELYN BENSONS RESPONSE TO
PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEFT
JOINT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER-EXHIBIT LIST
5/7/2021 MIFILE POS
05/07/2021INTERVENING DEF'T JOCELYN BENSONS RESPONSET TO
PLTF'S OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING
DEF'TS JOINT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER/5/7/21
MIFILE POS
05/07/2021MBDEF'T JOCELYN BENSONS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S
OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING IN PART
PLTF'S MOTION TO EXTEND DISCOVERY AND DATES
5/7/2021 MIFILE POS
05/07/2021DEF'T JOCELYN BENSONS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S
OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING IN PART
PLTF'S MOTION TO EXTEND DISCOVERY AND DATES/
EXHIBIT LIST/5/7/2021 MIFILE POS
05/07/2021DEF'T JOCELYN BENSONS RESPONSE TO PTLF'S
OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS
MOTION TO COMPEL DEPOSITIONS AND DENYING PLTF'S
MOTION FOR A PROTECTIVE ORDER-EXHIBIT LIST/
5/7/2021 MIFILE POS
05/07/2021MBDEF'T JOCELYN BENSONS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S
OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEF'TS
MOTION TO COMPEL DEPOSITIONS AND DENYING PLT'FS
MOTION FOR A PROTECTIVE ORDER/5/7/2021
MIFILE POS
05/07/2021EXHIBIT 2-PLTF'S COLLECTIVE RESPONSE TO DEF'TS
AND NON PARTY TOWNSHIPS MOTIONS TO QUASH AND FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDERS/5/7/2021
MIFILE POS
05/07/2021EXHIBIT 3 TO PLTF'S COLLECTIVE RESPONSE TO DEF'TS
AND NON PARTY TOWNSHIPS MOTIONS TO QUASH AND FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDERS/5/7/2021
MIFILE POS
05/07/2021EXHIBIT 1 TO PLTF'S COLLECTIVE RESPONSE TO DEF'TS
AND NON PARTY TOWNSHIPS MOTIONS TO QUASH AND FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDERS/5/7/2021
MIFILE POS
05/07/2021MBPLTF'S COLLECTIVE RESPONSE TO DEF'TS AND NON PARTY
TOWNSHIPS MOTIONS TO QUASH AND FOR PROTECTIVE
ORDERS/5/7/2021
MIFILE POS
05/10/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-PLTF'S EMERGENCY EX PARTE MOTION
FOR STATUS CONFERENCE AND TO AMEND MOTION
SCHEDULE-5/10/2021 @1:30PM VIA ZOOM
05/10/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-DEF'TS MOTION FOR A PROTECTIVE
ORDER TO PRECLUDE THE DEPOSITION OF MICHIGAN
SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSON 5/18/2021
@1:30PM VIA ZOOM
05/10/2021MRPLTF'S SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF/5/10/2021
MIFILE POS
05/10/2021EXHIBIT 1 TO SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF/5/10/2021
MIFILE POS
05/10/2021LIMITED APPEARANCE -BARRY COLE TO MANCELONA TWP
5/10/2021
MIFILE POS
05/11/2021APAPPEARANCE FILED-ALLAN VANDERLAAN VOR DEF'T ANTRIM
COUNTY/5/11/2021
MIFILE POS
05/11/2021W/DWITHDRAWAL OF ATTORNEY HAIDER KAZIM FOR ANTRIM
COUNTY/5/11/2021
MIFILEPOS
05/12/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-ORAL OPINION TO BE GIVEN VIA
ZOOM 5/18/2021 @1:30PM VIA ZOOM
05/12/2021OBJDE'FT JOCELYN BENSONS OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER
GRANTING PLTF'S MOTION TO AMEND EXPERT WITNESS
LIST/5/12/2021 -EXHIBIT LIST TO OBJECTION
MIFILE POS
05/13/2021HRGNOTICE OF HEARING-DEF'T JOCELYN BENSONS
OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING PLTF'S
MOTION TO AMEND EXPERT WITNESS LIST 5/18/2021
@1:30PM VIA ZOOM
05/13/2021MBBRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEF'T ANTRIM COUNTY'S
RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLT'FS MOTION TO
AMEND COMPLAINT/5/13/2021
MIFILE POS
05/13/2021EXHIBIT LIST TO BRIEF/5/13/2021
MIFILE POS
05/13/2021MRDEF'T ANTRIM COUNTY'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO
PLTF'S MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT/5/13/2021
MIFILE POS
05/14/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/5/14/2021
05/14/2021MRDEF'TS JOCELYN BENSONS RESPONSE TO PLTFS MOTION
FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT-EXHIBIT LIST/5/14/21
05/14/2021MODEF'TS EX PARTE MOTION FOR EXCESS PAGES/5/14/2021
05/14/2021PROOF OF SERVICE/5/14/2021
05/14/2021MBINTERVENING DEF'T JOCELYN BENSONS RESPONSE TO
PLTF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT/
5/14/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 1-2 TO PLTF'S MOTION TO DISQUALIFY
CUMMINGS MCLCOREY DAVIS & ACHO PLC/5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBIT 3 TO PLTF'S RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER TO PRECLUDE THE DEPOSITION OF
MICHIGAN SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSON/
5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBIT 7 TO PLTF'S MOTION TO DISQUALIFY CUMMINGS
MCCLOREY DAVIS AND ACHO PLC/5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 1-2 TO PLTF'S OBJECTION TO WITHDRAWAL OF
APPEARANCE OF ATTORNEY HAIDER KAZIM/5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 5-6 TO PLTF'S MOTION TO DISQUALIFY
CUMMINGS MCCLOREY DAVIS & ACHO PLC/5/17/2021
05/17/2021OBJPLTF'S OBJECTION TO WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE OF
ATTORNEY HAIDER KAZIM/5/17/2021
05/17/2021MRPLTF'S RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER TO
PRECLUDE THE DEPOSITION OF MICHIGA SECRETARY
OF STATE JOCELYN BENSON/5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 1-2 TO PLTF'S RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDER TO PRECLUDE THE DEPOSITION OF
MICHIGAN SECRETARY OF STATE JOCELYN BENSON/
5/17/21
05/17/2021MOPLTF'S MOTION TO DISQUALIFY CUMMINGS MCCLOREY
DAVIS & ACHO PLC/5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 8-9 TO PLTF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT/
5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 3-4 TO PLTF'S MOTION TO DISQUALIFY
CUMMINGS MCCLOREY DAVIS & ACHO PLC/5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBIT 10 TO PLTF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT/5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBIT 11 -TO PLTF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT/
5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 27-29 TO PLTF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT/
5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 5-7 TO PLTF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT/5/17/21
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 14-16 TO PLTF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT/
5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 12-13 TO PLTF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT/
5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 30-32 TO PLTF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT/
5/17/2021
05/17/2021MBSUPPLEMENTS TO PLTF'S MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT/
5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 1-4 TO PLTF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT/
5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBIT A TO SUPPLEMENT TO MOTION FOR LEAVE TO
FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT/ 5/17/2021
05/17/2021EXHIBITS 17-26 TO PLTF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT/
5/17/2021